Subscribe to South Asia Citizens Wire | feeds from | @sacw
Home > Communalism Repository > India - Maharashtra: Rashtra Seva Dal’s Inquiry Report into Bhima-Koregaon (...)

India - Maharashtra: Rashtra Seva Dal’s Inquiry Report into Bhima-Koregaon Riots

27 January 2018

print version of this article print version

The following is the fact-finding report on Rashtra Seva Dal’s inquiry into the Bhima-Koregaon riots conducted by the Rashtra Seva Dal. The inquriy team was headed by Dr Suresh Khairnar, the President of the Rashtra Seva Dal.

Located at the eastern side of Pune and situated on the banks of River Bhima, Koregaon-Bhima can be traced along the Pune-Ahmadnagar highway and approximately 25 km from the Pune City; its population is around 7000-8000.

January 1, 2018 was the occasion of celebrating the completion of 200 years of the Bhima-Koregaon battle. It is considered to be a valour day for the Mahar Regiment and this was initiated by Dr B.R. Ambedkar nearly 90 years ago in 1927. From 1927 to 2018 the number of people belonging to and consisting of depressed classes from all over Maharashtra increased magnificently from a few thousands to nearly around 1.5 million this year. Prior to this year’s conglomeration a substantial number of conferences were held all over Maharashtra in which hundreds of anti-caste groups under the banner of Elgaar had participated and they included the Rashtra Seva Dal also. These conferences facilitated the record turnout at Bhima-Koregaon this year. The State administration was well-informed about all these developments.

In the year 1990-91, on the special occasion of the death anniversary of Mahatma Jyotirao Phule and the birth centenary of Dr B.R. Ambedkar, a decision was taken to celebrate certain historical events like the establishment of the first women’s school at Bhidewada, Pune and the locations having historical significance like the birthplace of Savitribai Phule at Naygaon, Pune. Along with that, it was also decided to commemorate those events which have hitherto remained marginalised like the installation of the first statue of Gautam Buddha by Dr B.R. Ambedkar on the Dehu road near Pune. Celebration of the victory memorial of the Bhima-Koregaon battle, as it was initiated by Dr B.R. Ambedkar on January 1, 1927, was also a part and parcel of this broader objective.

The Bhima-Koregaon war was fought between the British forces on the one hand and the Peshwas’ forces on the other. In that the Peshwas had near-about 20,000 soldiers while the British regiment, known as the Bombay Native Infantry, 2nd battalion consisted of merely around 1000 soldiers. However, the latter were armed with better quality of arms and ammunition. This particular regiment consisted of the Mahar community soldiers in a majority. Ultimately, the battle won by the British resulted in the downfall of the Peshwa regime. It was during this regime that atrocities related to the caste system were at its peak and the then untouchables along with women were at the receiving end. They were the most severe victims of caste-oppression and humiliation. The then untouchables were required to carry a pot hung from their chest to belly so that whenever they spit the matter should not fall on the ground as it was considered to be impure. Further, a broom was also used to be tied at the back of their waist so that while walking on the ground the impure traces of their footprints automatically get cleaned and cleared. This humiliation was the most prominent reason behind the Mahar community’s participation in the brave fight from the British side. That’s the reason behind Dr Ambedkar’s commemoration of the event as a Victory Day.

Another version of this episode was that the end of the Peshwa regime did not automatically result in putting a full stop to the caste oppression. Instead, in the aftermath of the 1857 Sepoy Mutiny (which is also being upheld as the First War of Independence within the ranks of nationalist historiography), the British regime assured both the Brahmins and the Muslims that they will not interfere in the religious affairs of the indigenous communities. They discontinued with the recruitment in the separate Mahar Regiment in accordance with this assurance. Thus, as per the proponents of this version of history, the British strategy should be looked upon with suspicion and thereby we should refrain ourselves from celebrating this battle as a Victory Day which, according to them, amounts to being anti-national. The descendents of the Peshwas along with the Hindutva forces hold on to this view and had also approached the court to demand a ban on the celebration of this day as a Victory Day. However, their petition was rejected by the court. Interestingly, the War Memorial has been standing at that place since the last 200 years with the martyrs’ names inscribed on it. These consist not only the names of the soldiers from the Mahar community; but a few Maratha and Other Backward Caste soldiers’ names are also visible alongside those names.

A few kilometres away from this memorial, a mausoleum of Chhatrapati Sambhaji is also situated at a village called Wadoo (Budruk). Renowned historian V.C. Bendre had discovered this mausoleum in the year 1939; this can be located in the Dalit locality of the village. Sambhaji, the then scholar of Sanskrit language, became an eyesore to the Brahmins as gaining the knowledge of Sanskrit was prohibited for the non-Brahmins on the basis of the Manu-smriti dictum. These Brahmins advised Aurangzeb to punish Sambhaji in accordance with the Manusmriti code which included brutalities like to take out one’s eyes for the crime of reading Sanskrit Vedas, to cut off the head for memorising those along with the body being cut into pieces. A fatwa was issued prohibiting the cremation of his body parts. However, there was one Govind Mahar who took up the responsibility of performing late Sambhaji’s last rites and duly cremated his body after sewing up those parts and pieces. Renowned historians, apart from V.C. Bendre, like Kamal Gokhle and Sharad Patil, had also corroborated this version.

However, there is another version coming from Hindutvavaadi forces that the body parts were not sewn by a Mahar but by a Maratha. Hence the Marathas of the village are claiming that it is the ancestor of a Maratha family, named Sevale, who had performed the last rites of Sambhaji. The Hindutvavaadi forces are giving this twist to the story of punishment to Sambhaji for the last 25 years in western Maharashtra which added fuel to fire in the riots on January 1.

On December 28, 2017, the existing family members of the Govind Mahar had put up a board indicating the direction towards Sambhaji’s mausoleum. However, certain miscreants from the same village removed the hoarding. They also removed and threw away the shed over the mausoleum of Govind Mahar. The latter’s family members lodged a police complaint and accordingly 49 people were arrested from the village. On January 1, 2018, a rumour spread like wildfire that some suspicious activity was taking place at Sambhaji Maharaj’s mausoleum. An organisation called Hindu Aaghadi had been active for quite some time in this area. They had been holding public meetings for the last three weeks and issuing warnings to the people that those who would assemble on January 1 would be considered as anti-national. One amongst them held a press conference on December 28, 2017 at Pune and publicly said that probably India was the only country in the entire world where some anti-national elements could celebrate the victory of a foreign power over the nationalist forces (that is, the Peshwas) and the incumbent government, instead of interrogating them, provides all facilities to hold such public gatherings.

On December 29, 30 and 31, 2017, law and order prevailed over Bhima-Koregaon, Wadoo (Budruk) along with Sanaswadi. However, some strangers were found loitering around these villages. The Bhima-Koregaon village council had passed a resolution to observe a shutdown on January 1, 2018 and had also submitted a copy of the resolution to the nearest Police Station at Shikrapur. But the police ignored it and grossly underestimated the situation.

On January 1, 2018 people from all over Maharashtra were approaching to gather at Bhima-Koregaon. On the other hand, thousands of people with saffron flags had assembled at Vadhu (Budruk) around 10 am. The open space around Bhima-Koregaon was filled with vehicles parked by those who came to celebrate the memorial and Victory Day. After parking their vehicles, people came walking for three-to-four kilometres towards the memorial and they included women, children and the elderly. Around 11 am, an attack was launched upon them by the bearers of the saffron flag. Hundreds of vehicles were burnt down. The riots escalated further towards the Sanaswadi and Chakan-Shikrapur road. The attackers were duly equipped with stones and sharp-edged weapons. A shop belonging to one Salim Inamdar was set ablaze. Petrol was freely used to burn the vehicles. A warehouse belonging to one Salim Khan was put on fire. A tyre-shop belonging to one Asgar Ali Ansari was burnt. His younger brother, who had taken shelter inside the shop, fled when the shop was put on fire. A cylinder in the adjacent hotel burst and gutted the shop Sarvesh Autolines belonging to one Bhausaheb Khetre. Two trucks (truck nos. MH-12-786 and MH-12- 2757) in front of one Razzak Bhai’s garage was set on fire. A shop belonging to one Shivraj Prajapati displaying the nameplate ‘Ranabhai Marble’ was looted. A warehouse of firewood belonging to one Haribhau Darekar was burnt.

One Dalit, by the name of Sudam Shankar Pawar, is a project-affected person who had been rehabilitated in the Sanaswadi and who had received two acres of land out of which one-and-a-half acre is used for sugarcane cultivation while in the rest of his land a Buddha Vihar has been built along with a meeting hall and an open space. He had also built 29 one-room row houses (chawls). On January 1, 2018, around 6 pm a crowd marching from the side of a steel factory entered his field and broke the vehicles parked in his open space and put on fire his sugarcane field from all sides and also broke the glass-panes of the Buddha Vihar. Interestingly, the houses and fields belonging to Darekar and Hargude remained intact; those were just in front of his home. Thus, it becomes apparent that the rioters had targeted only Sudam Pawer’s house and field because he was a Dalit. Similarly, the attackers also pelted stones towards the houses of Ravi Kamble and Athwale. The studio of a famous painter and sculptor, Elvin Fernandes, was also burnt. The property of Mutha Jain was put on fire. On the Pune-Ahmednagar Road, the fire brigade vehicle was also set on fire. A total of 5000 vehicles were destroyed. Fifty cars and luxury buses were burnt.

The following questions can be raised with regard to the whole incidents:

1. Who took the decision for the shutdown on January 1, 2018? How come a village, which claims to provide hospitality to outsiders every year, gave a call for shutdown on that very day this year? As a result of which the visitors did not even get a glass of water to drink.

2. We noticed tremendous fear among the common people in Bhima-Koregaon; they requested us repeatedly not to write their names in our report. Due to this same fear, the existing family members of Govind Mahar of Vadoo-Budruk, who had filed a case earlier, have retracted now. All 49 people who were arrested in the case of destruction of Govind Mahar’s mausoleum have now been released. What is the cause of this fear psyche?

3. The Hindutva forces, that are clearly involved in this entire episode, are roaming freely, giving interviews and putting up distorted video clippings on social media putting the entire blame on the Dalits for whatever happened. What is the State administration doing?

4. This whole episode clearly indicates an attempt directed at dividing the Dalits and the Marathas along caste lines thereby disrupting the social fabric of Maharashtra. Why are the law and order agencies not paying any attention to the polarisation effect taking place due to this incident?

Our demands are as follows:

1. Arrest immediately the main culprits involved in the riots of Bhima-Koregaon.

2. A judicial inquiry must be immediately instituted and it should duly publish its report.

3. The role of the police and the administration should be investigated and the guilty persons should be punished accordingly.

4. The role of the media in this entire episode should be scrutinised.

The team members of the Rashtra Seva Dal who conducted this fact-finding were:

1. Dr Suresh Khairnar (President)

2. Allauddin Sheikh

3. Vinay Sawant

4. Feroz Mithiborewala

5. Puja Badekar

6. Shivraj Suryavanshi in association with

7. Bharat Patankar and

8. Kishor Dhamale